Wouldn't such an intervention in the brain change our identity?
Identity is not a static snapshot of every single second of our lives. Even today, we forget the names of former school friends or details from our youth without concluding that we have died since then. Our identity is defined by the memories that we consolidate by recalling them often and that remain stable even as superficial information fades. This process of selective storage stays exactly the same - regardless of whether we live to be 80 or 500 years old.
Biology confirms this continuity. The brain is a dynamic system that constantly breaks down and renews cellular components. Every single molecule and organelle in your head today is different from the ones you had as a child. Remarkably, this constant replacement extends all the way to the supracellular level: even in adulthood, the brain keeps reshaping its synaptic connections and even forms new nerve cells in regions such as the hippocampus.⁵ The medical replacement of lost nerve cells is essentially just a more targeted continuation of the remodeling that is already taking place. As long as these repairs take place gradually and on a small scale, and not everything is replaced at once, the structural patterns that make you who you are remain fully intact. It is the classic Ship of Theseus applied to medicine: you remain the same person because the change happens seamlessly.
In fact, most interventions in the brain do not even need to touch your synaptic connections. Clearing out waste products in and between cells or removing senescent glial cells restores brain function while leaving your memories untouched. So rejuvenation therapies are not about resetting the mind to zero, but rather about giving your personality and life experience room to continue to develop.