Skip to content

Isn't it death that makes life meaningful in the first place

Isn't it death that makes life meaningful in the first place?

The question of the connection between the finiteness of life and its meaning is a thought-provoking idea that philosophers in particular like to raise, and raise often. They frequently compare life to a piece of music or a story, which, they say, only gets its direction, its message and thus its meaning from the fact that it has an end. It does not have to be a happy ending, after all.

Regardless of whether life can really be compared to a story in this respect (and whether this comparison should be used to decide medical questions), there is a sound counterargument: the entire comparison is based on the assumption that, once the story is over, you never want to read another story again. The idea that for every person there must be exactly one story, lasting around 80 years on average, and not, for example, an ongoing volume with many short stories, has no logical basis. One could just as well take the view that it is life that gives us the opportunity to produce meaningful stories (in the metaphorical sense) in the first place, and that the longer we live, the more meaningful stories we can produce. In other words, the victory over aging would merely give every person more time and resources to find and fulfill a meaning in their life.

<< Back to "Concerns and Objections"